Practice 7 was another thud practice as the team went light in preparation for Saturday’s scrimmage. The second scrimmage is usually much more crisper during spring and I expect that to be the case based off how practice 7 went.
I can’t get into this without first mentioning that this was the first practice where SDSU, like last spring and fall, had major issues with the center to quarterback exchange.
There were two or three flat out fumbles on the snap, at least once in shotgun and from under center, and it completely wiped out the momentum of the offense at times.
It’s not a coincidence that Nick Gerhard took a lot of reps at guard on this particular day.
Keith Ismael and Derrick Achayo got a lot of playing time at center. So put two and two together.
After viewing this, I’d put Achayo ahead of Ismael at center as of now. Both aren’t great at snapping, and Achayo very well may not be as consistent as a snapper, but I came away more confident in Achayo as the overall blocker after the snap.
Ismael didn’t look to great in pass protection while Achayo showed better technique on his initial steps and moved his feet throughout the blocks.
-Another big takeaway is that I actually think Nick Gerhard may be better off, long term, at guard. He’s tremendous as a pulling guard, blocking in space and just running people over. But he also happens to be the best center on the current roster and SDSU’s backups aren’t as proficient at that position as they are at guard.
This leads me to believe that the coaching staff may be crossing its fingers that Dominic Gudino can come in and start right away as a freshman center, allowing Gerhard to be the left guard. Speaking of Gudino, he was at practice for a bit. He’s going to be one of the smaller lineman on the roster but as long as he didn’t forget how to snap, I wouldn’t write him off just because Gerhard seems to be the best center, now that Gerhard looks just as comfortable at left guard.
The rest of the standouts have continued to play well so if it sounds like I’m repeating myself, take that as a sign of consistency if you’ve followed along with each post(s).
-Sergio Phillips and Myles Cheatum have continued to play very well on the defensive line while Antonio Rosales and Ryan Pope (when he’s locked in) have looked like the best offensive lineman.
-Daishawn Dixon and JonDarius Gardner are still one dimensional players that still have potential. Dixon is very comfortable as a pulling guard but seems to really struggle in isolated pass pro. He’s also another guy who misreads/mishandles blitzes at times.
There was one play in particular where Parker Baldwin was playing man coverage on the running back, so after the snap he started running toward the line of scrimmage before covering the flat. Dixon misread him as a blitz and ended up whiffing on the DE twisting around him, untouched, and into the backfield. Agnew got the pass off to Chase Jasmin in the flat in time for a decent gain (Baldwin didn’t let him get up the sideline) but it was another example of the blitzes giving the OL a hard time.
-Gardner’s size will be a used asset come fall but I really like how the ends are looking. The idea of having Hall and Turner start out there, then to send in Chibu and Cheatham on passing downs with Ricks or Henderson coming off the edge is worth getting excited about.
Overall, though, I felt like the OL was much more in sync when protecting against the blitz, especially when the defense sent an extreme blitz with 7 or even 8 guys.
There weren’t as many guys making it into the backfield without a lineman getting a chip block in or at least altering the angle.
They are getting engaged into blocks instead of looking around as the QB gets sacked. They’re still reacting late to stunts and twists which makes them off balanced but I still feel like we should see an improvement during the scrimmage.
-Zach Thomas is making a case to be the third offensive tackle, although I still believe Pope, Roemer and Salcedo to have the most potential. Thomas looked very good during the live periods. He has the least potential as a pass blocker but he always seems to get a body on a body on run plays and can reposition his feet well when the defense tries to blitz him from him angle he isn’t prepared for.
SDSU’s depth at the tackle position has a chance to be in a better spot than last fall if Salcedo can stay healthy.
-At the skill positions, Kameron Kelly is starting to turn the corner at corner. He’s using his EYES much better instead of just staying down either the QB or WR the entire rep. He’s still not someone that will stick to his receiver throughout the route but he’ll get downfield fast enough to play deep balls. He also won’t be on the hip of the receiver than shorter routes (like drags) but he’s athletic enough to cut off any potential big yards after the catch and make open field stops.
-I noticed Quest Truxton taking more reps at the slot position when SDSU went with three wide receiver packages.
-Liam Cabrera also had another good day and I was happy to hear Coach Cooper mention him as a standout the other day. He’s a very quick route runner that could be used a dangerous open field guy like Cal used Bug Rivera last season.
-Jeff Clay’s progress in pass coverage has been tremendous. He’s using his hands much better and playing the ball cleanly (not interfering) - stuff that he wasn’t being mindful of at all last spring. I’d put him ahead of Dwayne Parchment at this point.
-Isaiah Macklin isn’t as consistent as you’d want but he makes big plays downfield and that’s worth noting. Tall guys are automatically labeled as red zone threats but I legitimately believe Mackling can feel that role based off his radius and jump ball skills. SDSU doesn’t practice all that many goal line situations unless it’s during scrimmages but Macklin has shown the ability to go up and get it on go routes.
-Darryl Richardson may have had his best day and his improvement as a receiver, I feel, is only making him more confident out there.
-Parker Houston did something I love to see in the passing game, which is breaking up would-be interceptions. Trenton Thompson was covering Houston on an out route, then pulled up a bit to bait Agnew into throwing it (or to protect against a potential wheel route by Houston), then jumped it at the last second. Houston was aware of him though and stopped his route to jump the ball himself, smacking it away to prevent an easy pick six.
That was a great matchup to watch between the two, arguably the biggest up and comers on both sides of the ball.
-I’m really liking Ronley Lakalaka’s aggressiveness against the run this year. You can tell he’s very confident in his reads, and although he hasn’t reached the level Jake Fely was at against the run, he’s very good at attacking stretch runs and getting out in front of the ball to force the running back to cut back earlier than he would like. That’s something Fely would do all the time and Lakalaka seems to have the same trait and instincts.
-Reggie Murphy is still well behind Henderson and Ricks but he’s the biggest of the edge rushers and he’s likely taken away a lot from Ricks and Henderson over the last year. Murphy looks very comfortable and balanced for a big guy coming off the edge - better than I remember. He’s still needs to get better in coverage though.
-Dwayne Johnson is a guy I’ve repeatedly said needs to improve in coverage but at least he’s still a physical guy. Keoni Stallworth is another safety that shows glimpses but needs a lot of reps to get to where he wants to be. He’’s hesitating when it comes to play recognition and is late to the play every now and then.
-Kyava Tezino and Troy Cassidy continue to look like a solid duo. Cassidy has been impressive with his drop back skills while Tezino has shown some ability rushing off the edge. Tezino was strictly a run stopper that could drop back in coverage last year but he’s become much more effective getting sent on the blitz.
-Will Stricklin started camp limited due to injury but he’s getting more involved and I like what I see. Very explosive and physical player.